A 13-year-old domestic worker, Fatima Asghar, died after alleged torture at the official residence of a senior Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) officer in Islamabad. CCTV clips and photographs have emerged showing the child being beaten with a stick while crying and pleading for mercy.

CCTV Evidence and Post-Mortem Findings

Footage available with The Express Tribune shows Fatima subjected to torture until around 40 minutes before her death. Photographs reveal marks of torture and burns across her body.

A post-mortem report from the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences (PIMS) documented approximately 20 major wounds and signs of prolonged, brutal violence extending from her head to her toes.

Arrests and Investigation

  • Victim: Fatima Asghar, 13 years old, employed as domestic helper
  • Location: Official accommodation of a senior FIA officer within Islamabad Police Lines Headquarters
  • Date of death: November 14
  • Case registered: November 15 at Shams Colony police station on father's complaint
  • Suspects arrested: Afshan Ali (officer's wife) and Qari Ali Raza (religious tutor)
  • Confessions: Both suspects admitted to torturing the child during interrogation
  • Evidence recovered: Stick and iron allegedly used in assault (November 18)
  • Remand: Extended by two days on Friday after initial four-day remand on November 16

Legal Context and Past Cases

The Islamabad Capital Territory Domestic Workers Act 2022 prohibits employment of children below 16 as domestic workers. Fatima, at 13, should have been protected under this law.

Her death highlights systemic failures in protecting child domestic workers. Recent cases include:

  • March 2024: 10-year-old boy in Rawalpindi allegedly beaten with pipes, deprived of food and water, locked in a room
  • July 2024: Six-year-old Allahrakhi in Vehari allegedly abused by employer, a relative, over minor mistakes
A May report by The Express Tribune on child labour in Punjab pointed to weak implementation of the Punjab Domestic Workers Act, 2019, inadequate monitoring of private households and ineffective mechanisms for addressing workers' complaints.

In Sindh, proposed legislation to regulate domestic employment and prohibit employment of children under 16 remains stalled, leaving many domestic workers without legal protections.