Supreme Court Grants Bail to Four in Placenta Smuggling Case
The Supreme Court of Pakistan granted post-arrest bail on Monday to four suspects arrested in the human placenta smuggling case. The bench included Justice Shahzad Ahmad Khan and Justice Aqeel Ahmed Abbasi.
The accused are three Chinese nationals and one Pakistani citizen. They were arrested by the Federal Investigation Agency’s Corporate Crime Circle in Islamabad.
Bail Conditions
The court granted bail to each accused against bail bonds of Rs1 million. Each bond must be backed by two local sureties.
Case Details and Recoveries
The case was registered under Sections 11 and 12 of the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, 2010, along with Sections 420, 34 and 109 of the Pakistan Penal Code. The complaint was filed by Hina Kanwal, a medical officer at the Human Organ Transplant Authority in Islamabad.
Joint teams of the FIA and HOTA raided a house in Sector F-7/1, Islamabad, which was allegedly being used as an unauthorised facility for collecting and storing human placentas. A second raid in Sector E-11 recovered more placentas from refrigerators.
- Around 400 to 500 kilogrammes of fresh and dried human placentas were recovered from the two locations.
- A 580 kilogramme shipment, allegedly misdeclared as sheep placenta, was intercepted at Islamabad International Airport. It was booked for export to Hanoi, Vietnam by Hair Traders, a company owned by a Faisalabad resident.
- The total recovery in the case was 1,241 kilogrammes.
Samples were sent to the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences for forensic examination.
Investigation and Legal Arguments
Deputy Attorney General Raja Shafqat Abbasi told the court that the suspects were allegedly involved in the illegal collection, preservation, processing, packaging and export of human placentas for commercial gain. The placentas were allegedly procured through a resident of Dhok Jabbi, Rawalpindi, who worked for Arrar Innovations, a company handling hospital waste at Benazir Bhutto Hospital.
Further investigation is underway to trace the financial trail and export chain and to establish whether Customs officials or personnel from other departments were involved.
The deputy attorney general argued that placenta is a human organ under Section 2(e) of the 2010 Act and that commercial dealings are punishable by up to 10 years in prison and a fine of Rs1 million. He also said the foreign nationals were a flight risk.
The court observed that the placenta is waste material and the matter requires further inquiry. A district and sessions court had previously rejected the bail applications of the four suspects in July. In July, the FIA was also investigating a syndicate suspected of smuggling human placenta from hospitals to produce anti-ageing injections.
Background on Placenta Use
Placenta is rich in protein, iron and fat and is believed by some to be nutritious. It has been made into pills and injections thought to help with tissue regeneration. Gynaecologist Sadaf Tariq said placenta is considered highly infectious medical waste and its disposal is strictly regulated.