German Professor Urges Pakistan to Build Middle-Power Alliances

Carlos Masala, a professor of security and defence policy at the University of the Federal Armed Forces in Munich, said Pakistan should form alliances with like-minded middle powers to resist pressure from the United States and China. He made the remarks on Friday at a seminar titled "The Evolution of the International Order and Current Structural Changes," held at the Institute of Business Administration (IBA) City Campus in Karachi.

Pressure to Pick a Side

Masala said the world is moving toward a bipolar system led by the United States and China. He warned that great powers have tools to coerce smaller countries, and the pressure on Pakistan to choose between Beijing and Washington would be extremely high.

His answer was for Pakistan to build as many alliances and partnerships as possible with middle powers that do not want to be permanently pressured into siding with either superpower.

Tragedy of Geography

Discussing Pakistan's "tragedy of geography," Masala said the country has a population of around 260 million but is sandwiched between much larger neighbours, India and China. He said Pakistan would have been a superpower if it were located in Europe, but is currently only a middle power.

He pointed to the recent Makkah pact as a strategic vacuum that could raise Pakistan's role and allow it to play a more independent part in the Persian Gulf and the Middle East.

Bipolar World Order

Masala, who called himself a structural realist, said multipolarity is an illusion because there is no evidence of several global poles. He argued the future international system will either be bipolar or a weakened unipolarity.

He divided countries into status quo powers and revisionist powers, not democracies and authoritarian states. He said China's rise can only be delayed, not stopped, and the relative decline of the United States supports a bipolar outlook.

To explain the balance of power, he compared the United States to an 800-pound gorilla and China to a 720-pound gorilla that could grow to 780 pounds. He said all other countries are like 50-pound monkeys.

Middle Powers Must Gang Up

Masala said most countries are hedging their bets and looking for a better offer from either the United States or China. He argued that middle powers like Pakistan need to gang up so they can face pressure from great powers trying to bring them into their spheres of influence.

He referred to comments by Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney at Davos in January 2026 and compared the current situation to the Yalta Conference of 1945. He also mentioned the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Summit set for November 18 and 19 in Shenzhen.

Russia and Ukraine

Answering audience questions, Masala said Russia is fighting a shadow war in Europe, including recent hoax bomb threats and supermarket attacks, to weaken support for Ukraine, although attribution remains difficult. He said the war in Ukraine is driven by Russia's imperial ambitions and territorial claims, not by NATO's eastward expansion.