Mohsin Naqvi Proposes Referendum on New Provinces
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has suggested holding a referendum to elicit public opinion on creating new provinces in Pakistan. The proposal comes as political parties continue to differ over the creation of more administrative units, although major parties have in principle supported more provinces.
Need for Devolution and New Provinces
Pakistan requires devolution of powers and an organic grassroots structure to address the socio-economic problems of a soaring population. The source says this is essential for good governance, satisfactory public service delivery, and ending disparities in the sharing of resources.
Constitutional Process for the Referendum
The referendum would be held under Article 48(6) and Article 48(7). It must transparently pass through the test of popular approval in a joint sitting of Parliament and be executed through a free and fair ballot. Some experts, however, insist that creating a new province still formally requires a constitutional amendment under Article 239.
Concerns About Credibility
Pakistan has a jaundiced history of referendums. Past ballots were solely dictatorial in essence and are widely mocked for lacking credibility. The proposed referendum must be different and should unite the nation rather than sow seeds of parochialism and dissent.
Steps the Government Must Take
- Take all political segments along to assure them the referendum will be non-partisan and thoroughly fair.
- Reconstitute the electoral watchdog to exhibit sincerity of purpose.
- Ensure the referendum is transparent and impartial.
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi started the debate by stating that the system has collapsed and a reset is desired. A credible referendum could generate the overwhelming public mandate needed to compel reluctant lawmakers to pass the requisite legislation.