Test Results in Karachi
The Federal Board of Revenue has released the results of a competency test for inland revenue officers in Karachi, and most of them failed to meet basic standards. The examination, ordered by the FBR chairman, covered officers in Grades 17 to 19 working in sales tax and income tax.
A total of 150 sales tax officers and 143 income tax officers took the open-book test. They had to find errors in draft orders and explain the legal reasons. No sales tax officer reached the 60 percent benchmark. Only four income tax officers scored 60 percent or above. The average score was 26.4 percent in sales tax and 33.3 percent in income tax. Forty-seven sales tax officers and 16 income tax officers scored below 20 percent.
Ability to Issue and Review Orders
Only 15 of the 150 sales tax officers met the standard to issue an order under their own signatures. In income tax, only 14 of the 143 officers could issue a correct order. Of 139 officers who took the combined test for both taxes, only four met the standard to issue correct orders in both categories.
For reviewing work done by others, only 21 sales tax officers could check the legal aspects of a case prepared by another officer. In income tax, 28 officers could review orders drafted by colleagues. Just eight officers could vet orders in both taxes.
Performance by Rank
Among sales tax commissioners and additional commissioners, only four of 56 met the review standard. In income tax, only six of 53 met it. Deputy commissioners performed better than other ranks, and most of those who could adjudicate or vet orders were in the Large Taxpayers Office. The report said higher grades did not guarantee stronger competence.
Main Weaknesses
- Officials could identify errors but struggled to explain the legal grounds.
- Thirty-one percent of sales tax entries identified mistakes that did not exist, compared with 24 percent in income tax.
- Fourteen officers were found unfit to handle cases in either category without retraining.
- Thirty-one officers were assessed at desk level or below in both categories.
FBR Recommendations
The report recommended training in adjudication, decision-making, evidence assessment and drafting orders. It proposed assigning work based on competence rather than designation and strengthening the order review system. The findings were based on three cases per category and should be treated as an initial indicator, the report clarified.