US President Donald Trump's unprecedented three-way summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen ended Thursday with only a symbolic declaration against nuclear war, exposing the limits of Trump's personalised diplomacy.
No Breakthroughs on Major Issues
The leaders met for less than 90 minutes during the APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting in the southern Chinese city. While they reaffirmed that nuclear war should never be fought and agreed to hold a nuclear risk reduction dialogue, they announced no timeline for arms control talks. There were no advances on Iran, Ukraine, Taiwan, trade, or artificial intelligence.
Analysts Call Outcome a Photo Opportunity
- Christopher Preble of the Stimson Centre said Trump got the pageantry he loves but "hard to see any substantive progress made on any major issue."
- German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, speaking in Berlin where European allies met to support Ukraine, called the summit "apparently first and foremost a photo op."
- US Senator Charles Schumer labelled it "a historic embarrassment that people will remember long into the future."
Trump Seeks International Reassertion
Trump entered the summit politically weakened after his Republican Party lost control of Congress in November midterm elections. He also faces an unpopular stalemate with Iran that has driven down his approval ratings. The meeting followed a pattern of leader-to-leader encounters since his return to office that have not yielded breakthroughs, including earlier meetings with Xi and Putin and first-term summits with North Korea's Kim Jong Un.
Xi and Putin Gain Diplomatic Ground
Analysts said Xi burnished his credentials by hosting a big-power gathering, while Putin presented Russia as appearing on par with the world's two most powerful economies without making concessions. The summit drew comparisons to the 1945 Yalta Conference, though Thursday's brief meeting lacked the detailed discussions and far-reaching decisions of that week-long wartime summit.
Nuclear Dialogue Agreed But No Timeline
"We need much more than rhetoric," said Daryl Kimball, executive director of the Arms Control Association, while calling the joint statement "positive." The three countries possess the world's largest nuclear arsenals.
Trump told Reuters a three-way nuclear arms deal is "a very hard thing" to achieve because China's arsenal is much smaller than those of the US and Russia. China has resisted such talks.
White House Defends Summit
White House spokeswoman Anna Kelly said Trump "effectively restored American strength" and "showcased the great respect and deference that world leaders bestow upon our country." Trump himself rated the meeting "12" on a scale of zero to 10.
Questions Remain for G20 in December
Analysts are watching what Trump plans for the G20 summit he will host in mid-December at his Florida golf resort, where he expects to meet Xi again and could potentially see Putin. With two years left in his presidency, Trump may continue his brand of personal diplomacy, though history will judge it by resolutions in Iran and Ukraine, said Josh Lipsky of the Atlantic Council.